The BEST Traditional Stuffing Recipe (2024)

This is the BEST traditional stuffing recipe you will ever make! How do I know this? How can I prove it? Simple, it's been tried and test for decades. It's a Thanksgiving stuffing recipe that's been handed down through generations! What's even better is how easy it is to make! Let me show you how!

Our family makes this homemade bread stuffing every Thanksgiving. We traditionally stuff it in a turkey while it bakes. But this homemade stuffing recipe works even when you fry or smoke a turkey instead of baking.

Either way the prep is pretty much the same. The method just changes slightly just before cooking! I'm showing you how to make it inside OR outside of the turkey!

If you're looking for an alternative moist stuffing recipe, definitely check our other recipe for a semi-homemade stuffing.

Why You Will Love This Herb Stuffing Recipe

• Simple ingredients and easy to make!
• A family-favorite recipe that's been tested for generations!
• Easy to prep elements ahead to make your holiday cooking easier!
• Great flavor and it works inside or outside the turkey!

Ingredients You Need

The ingredient list for homemade stuffing is pretty simple. You may already have some on hand and the rest are easy to find in most grocery stores.

• Bread: You will need two loaves of quality white bread. Since stuffing is primarily all bread you really do want to choose a bread with great taste. I love to use an Italian or french loaf, or the brand artesno.
• Eggs: Give the bread to have a nice fluffy texture.
• Butter: For a rich, creamy flavor.

• Vegetables: Onions, carrots, and green pepper give the stuffing flavor and texture.
• Herbs for stuffing: We will be using sage, oregano leaves, and thyme.
• Garlic powder: A handy pantry staple to add a bit more flavor.

How to Make Homemade Stuffing

Here's an overview of the steps involved in making the BEST homemade stuffing recipe! For detailed instructions, check the recipe card at the end of the post.

1. Tear the bread into crouton size pieces and lay out on a cookie sheet for about 24 hours so it dries out. Toss the bread every so often.

PRO TIP: If you forget to leave it out the night before you can dry it out faster by putting it in the oven at 200 degrees. every 20-30 minutes toss the bread so that all sides dry out. For more flavor, sprinkle a little bit of your seasonings on the moist bread before it dries, the flavors of the seasonings will infuse into the bread.

2. Grate all your veggies so that they evenly spread throughout the bread and cook perfectly with the bread. It's simple enough to grate the onion, bell pepper and carrot using your cheese grater.

3. Whip the eggs and add to the melted butter.
4. Gather the sage, thyme, oregano leaves, a good garlic salt and salt. Herbs are what make stuffing so delicious, I mean otherwise it would just be bread right? Combine everything together and mix it up!

RECIPE NOTE: When you bake the stuffing inside the turkey the drippings and juice from the turkey body will moisten the bread so you do NOT need to add any broth to the bread and seasonings. However, when you bake the homemade stuffing outside the turkey you will need to add broth!

Do I bake the stuffing inside or outside the turkey?

Really both methods work just fine! But in my opinion, if you are baking a turkey, I 100% recommend stuffing it! The natural and organic flavors that comes from the bread baking with all the delicious salty turkey flavor is incredible!

Here's what you need to do for each method.

How to Bake Stuffing INSIDE the Turkey

Follow all the steps above EXCEPT do not add the broth. Toss all your ingredients together so the bread cubes are coated.

Open the legs and stuff the turkey cavity completely full of the stuffing. Squish and squeeze it really tight in there!

PRO TIP: Check your packaging of your turkey. It may have the giblets and neck inside the cavity of the bird. If so, remove them before stuffing the cavity with the bread stuffing.

How to Cook Stuffing OUTSIDE the Turkey

Follow all the steps above, including adding the chicken broth, and stir until well combined.

Bake uncovered for bout 45 minutes and you are ready!! Thats so incredible easy right?

How to Store

• Refrigerator: Store leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for up to five days.
• Freezer: Leftover bread stuffing with herbs can also be stored in the freezer. Wrap it up well and freeze for up to three months. Thaw it out in the fridge overnight before reheating.
• Reheat: Return the mixture to an oven-safe container and spread it out. You may want to add some additional broth as it will likely be a bit drier after cooking again. Heat in a 325° F oven for 20-30 minutes or until heated through. To save time you can also reheat in the microwave.

Can I make homemade stuffing ahead?

Yes and no. There are some steps you can take but some will need to wait until the day of your dinner.

You can definitely dry your bread and prepare all of your ingredients such as the grated vegetables individually. Store them in air tight containers (bread in a gallon bag would be fine, or the bread bag it came in.

For best results, I would not bake it ahead of time as reheating it may cause the stuffing to be too dry.

What to Serve with Homemade Stuffing

When it comes to the sides to serve with homemade stuffing, of course the traditional turkey goes great! If your serving fried turkey, follow the method for making the stuffing outside the turkey.

If you decide to brine a turkey, it's totally fine to add the stuffing inside after brining and before baking.

Don't forget to make a batch of Homemade Turkey Gravy! It's great to add a spoonful over the top of your stuffing.

Other favorite Thanksgiving sides to consider are creamy mashed potatoes, candied green beans, or bacon brussel sprouts.

If you're craving some bread to serve up with the meal. I love these homemade rolls or crescent rolls.

Don't forget the homemade cranberry sauce and of course a pumpkin pie!

Expert Tips

• Use a quality bread! It really makes a difference to the overall flavor of the stuffing. I recommend a French or Italian loaf.
• Don't forget to add the broth if you are cooking the stuffing on its own and not inside the turkey.
• Stuff your turkey the day you plan to cook for food safety reasons!
• Make sure to dry out the bread ahead of time or use the quick oven method if you forget. It needs to be dry before combining with the other ingredients so it cooks properly.
• If you only need to make half a recipe it will feed about 6-8 people. You can bake it in a large pie dish or 8x8 pan.

More Holiday Dishes You'll Love

If you're looking for a gluten-free stuffing, check out this delicious recipe!

Keep In Touch!

If you tried this homemade traditional stuffing recipe or any other recipe on the blog then don’t forget torate the recipeand leave us a comment below. You can also follow us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagramand Pinterestto see what else we’re getting up to!